Pool Chlorine vs Pool Bromine: Which Is The Best Choice For Your Ice Bath?

chlore piscine vs brome piscine

Any pool or cold tub owner knows that pool or ice tub maintenance is a primary task for safe and enjoyable swimming. But which is the better choice between chlorine and bromine? Let's take a closer look!

Understanding Chlorine and Bromine

What is Chlorine ?

Chlorine is the most commonly used disinfection agent for swimming pools. It effectively removes bacteria, viruses and algae, ensuring clean and clear water.

What is Bromine?

Bromine is an alternative to chlorine, particularly appreciated for its mildness. It is often used in spas due to its performance at higher temperatures and less odor.

Use of Chlorine and Bromine in Swimming Pools

Chlorine in Swimming Pools

Advantages :

Chlorine is powerful, fast and affordable. It offers direct and rapid control over water quality.

Disadvantages :

Chlorine can be irritating to skin and eyes, and its odor can be unpleasant to some.

Bromine in Swimming Pools

Advantages :

Bromine is less irritating to skin and eyes, and does not have a strong odor. It is also more effective at higher temperatures.

Disadvantages :

Bromine is generally more expensive than chlorine and acts more slowly to purify water.

Differences between Chlorine and Bromine

There are several key differences between chlorine and bromine. Chlorine is stronger and faster, but can be irritating. Bromine, on the other hand, is gentle and effective at high temperatures, but costs more and acts more slowly.

swimming pool chlorine vs swimming pool bromine

Choosing between Chlorine and Bromine

Factors to Consider

The choice between chlorine and bromine depends on several factors. You should consider your personal preferences, cost, skin and eye sensitivity, pool temperature and frequency of use.

Precautions when Using Chlorine and Bromine

Whether you choose chlorine or bromine, it is essential to handle these chemicals with care. Be sure to follow the manufacturer's instructions and store chemicals in a safe place, out of direct sunlight and out of reach of children.

The Best Choice Between Bromine and Chlorine for an Ice Bath

When it comes to an ice bath, the choice between bromine and chlorine can depend on various factors such as longevity, cost and the amount required for a specific volume of water (270-320L in this case).

Bromine might be a more suitable choice for an ice bath. Because of its stability at lower temperatures, bromine retains its effectiveness longer than chlorine in the cold conditions of an ice bath. Plus, it's less irritating to the skin and eyes, which could be a plus for those who use the ice bath frequently.

However, bromine is generally more expensive than chlorine. For a 270-320L ice bath, the amount of bromine needed would be less compared to chlorine, which could offset its higher initial cost in the long run.

All in all, although bromine is a bit more expensive to purchase, its effectiveness in cold temperatures and its gentleness to the skin and eyes might make it the preferred choice for an ice bath.

bromine ice bath


Ultimately, the choice between chlorine and bromine comes down to your specific pool and cold tub needs. Understanding the pros and cons of each is key to making the best decision. Either way, proper and consistent use of these chemicals will ensure clean, safe pool water for your enjoyment.


  1. Is bromine better for the skin than chlorine?

    Yes, bromine is generally considered to be kinder to the skin and eyes than chlorine.

  2. Is bromine more expensive than chlorine?

    Yes, bromine is generally more expensive than chlorine.

  3. Can I switch from chlorine to bromine in my pool?

    Yes, you can switch from chlorine to bromine, but it requires a proper conversion process. It is recommended to consult a professional before making the change.

  4. Can chlorine and bromine be used together in a swimming pool?

    No, chlorine and bromine should not be used together as they can react and cause health issues.

  5. What is the alternative to chlorine and bromine for the swimming pool?

    There are several alternatives to chlorine and bromine for swimming pools, including ozone and saltwater pool systems.